1. In accordance with the FINA Rules, a review by the FINA Doping Panel of a decision rendered by a member federation can be ordered by the Executive if it “believes” that the member federation has not followed the applicable FINA Rules. The requirement for such review is the belief that an erroneous application of the FINA Rules has, firstly, been committed and, secondly, that the erroneous application was committed by the member federation. Concerning the belief of an erroneous application of the FINA Rules, the CAS holds that such an evaluation lies within the sole judgment of the FINA Executive and that the Panel has no authority to review the Executive’s exercise of such judgment.